The Higher Court in Podgorica overturned the verdict of the Basic Court, which granted Velizar Kaluđerović the right to compensation for non-pecuniary damage from the state in the amount of 3.000 euros due to a publication on the former Udar portal, where he was nicknamed "Kalimero" and called a collaborator of Serbian security services.
The verdict was overturned due to the lack of a clear explanation of exactly how Kaluđerović's right to honor and reputation was violated, but also due to the unclear connection between the state's inaction and the resulting damage.
The Higher Court returned the proceedings to the Basic Court for a retrial.
In its decision, the Higher Court points out that it has not been proven that the nickname "Kalimero" itself constitutes an insult:
"Since 'Kalimero' is a fighter for justice, who perceives as injustice any action that, in his opinion, threatens his rights," the High Court ruling states.
The former member of the Parliament of Montenegro claimed during the first proceedings before the Basic Court that the publication “brutally affected” him and that the aim was to cause political damage, stressing that he was particularly hurt by the fact that the state had not reacted to the publication for years. The Ministry of Culture and Media, as the defendant, contested the state’s liability, claiming that there was no evidence that their lack of oversight over the media directly led to the damage.
The decision of the Higher Court, which “Vijesti” had access to, states that during the proceedings, Kaluđerović was heard as a party, and the first-instance court accepted his testimony. Kaluđerović, according to the decision, said that he was “deeply troubled by the fact that the competent authorities have not taken any action for almost three years to determine who is behind everything”, but also claimed that behind the publication “there is a certain group of people, including individuals who were entrusted with the service in the National Security Agency”.
"However, the Higher Court declared this conclusion of the first instance court unacceptable... The prosecutor did not specifically state anywhere how his personal rights were violated. He did not explain anywhere that his personal rights were violated by the fact that he was labeled with the nickname 'Kalimero' in the post on that portal, nor was there a clear explanation of the derogatory nature of that nickname. On the contrary, the Higher Court pointed out that 'Kalimero' can also refer to a fighter for justice, which in itself does not imply offensiveness. Kaluđerović specifically referred to the fact that the competent authorities did not react to the post for a long time," the Higher Court's decision states.
The Higher Court in Podgorica previously upheld the verdicts of the Kotor and Podgorica Basic Courts in which the state was found guilty, because "Vijesti" journalist Vuk Lajović and Serbian Orthodox Church (SPC) priest Gojko Perović found themselves targeted by that portal.
The "Udar" portal appeared on the eve of the 2020 parliamentary elections, and it led a campaign against critics of the then government - journalists, politicians, civil activists, and citizens who were labeled as collaborators of foreign services and enemies of the state.
The controversial portal was removed from the internet a few days after the elections, while the YouTube channel still contains video materials published during August 2020. Kaluđerović is one of many who sued the state because they were the target of that portal, and the verdicts of the first-instance courts mostly found the state guilty because the Ministry of Culture and Media failed to ensure compliance with the law, that is, failed to establish the identity of the person, the founder of that media outlet.
See more:
Download the app and follow the news
FOLLOW US ON