It is questionable what it means in the economy to increase the salaries of a certain number of employees in Montenegro, and the price of all this is that the number of employees in Montenegro is falling, said Maja Baćović, professor at the Faculty of Economics, University of Montenegro.
Baćović said this in an interview on the show Načisto, whose topic was "Euromodel - long-term solution or dangerous electoral fraud?", which airs tonight on Television Vijesti.
The interview with Baćović was conducted by the editor and host of the show Načisto, Petar Komnenić.
Komnenić: Have the conditions been met, as the Prime Minister says in his initial, rather euphoric address, for people's incomes to increase dramatically, or do official data suggest something else?
"As for the impression itself, it was a surprise, I believe for all of us, including me. Especially since that administratively determined wage growth was definitely not expected, because, for example, maybe if you remember or if you looked at the reports of the International Monetary Fund, which were published maybe just a few months before the launch of this model, they suggested that, for example, wage growth should be stopped, that in principle wage growth must be aligned with the dynamics of productivity. Even without the International Monetary Fund, it seems to me that this was heard quite often from this side. Again, we had those, we could hear about negotiations related to the collective agreement, which were quite slow, practically and unsuccessful, so at least I personally did not expect that there would be any wage growth this year," said Baćović.
Komnenić: Where is this leading us, how big a hole is it creating, and how can that hole be filled?
"Data from the structural business statistics and national accounts of Montenegro say that wage costs account for 60 percent of gross value added in Montenegro, which means that it is an input or cost category of employers, the change of which most significantly affects the final costs of doing business. So if you increase the cost to employers by 20 percent with such a high share of labor costs, even if you decide to keep the operating surplus or what we call the gross margin at an unchanged level and only possibly slightly adjust the investment costs given that of course you have to purchase investment equipment, let's assume that you import it so that the price change is lower, so just on the basis of the cost increases that I mentioned, employers, in order to be able to pay those costs, have to increase their income, meaning the sale of their goods, by approximately 13 percent. If we assume that they can realistically increase production by three percent, which is the Montenegrin average, that means that on that cost side alone, inflation in Montenegro from domestic sources would increase by approximately nine to ten percent in the best case scenario. If we were, for example, "If we look at it from the other side, which is inflation driven by demand growth, household deposits in this scenario would increase by approximately 500 million or some 19 percent, combined with a GDP growth rate of three percent, this would further stimulate price growth in Montenegro, because wages will grow not only in the economy, but also in the public sector, so the purchasing power of citizens will definitely be higher. When we sum it all up, we can very simply and without any major analysis reach an inflation rate of some 14-15 percent," said Baćović.
Komnenić: What does this mean for the standard of living of citizens? What will their real purchasing power and standard of living be tomorrow?
"Regarding the standard of living of citizens, if we know that net income will increase by about 35 percent, all those categories of the population that currently have below-average income will have some positive effect in terms of purchasing power growth in the first year of implementation. Because that means your income will increase by 35 percent, your prices will increase by about 15 percent, so you are still in the plus of about 20 percent. This only applies to categories of the population that currently have lower and below-average incomes. So not all incomes will increase linearly, not everyone's income will increase by 35 percent. It will increase by 35 percent for categories with lower incomes, but for those with higher incomes, for example, where the growth may only be caused by a drop in PIO contributions, that growth will perhaps be around 15 percent and it will be completely neutralized. But I think that the other problem that is not being talked about is related to inflation, and that is, if you have inflation of 15 percent, that means that the selling price of all your products and services is increasing. So we are leaving with inflation of 15 percent "to the international market with all products and services that are 15 percent more expensive, including tourism services," said Baćović.
Komnenić: Our competitiveness is declining
"Last week, the World Economic Forum published reports on the global competitiveness of the tourism industry. For some reason, Montenegro was not ranked, I don't know why, but let's say our neighboring, very competitive Albania was declared the global winner in all categories. Albania has improved its competitive position, I think by 15 or 16 places compared to 2024. And so it is already in a position that is better than the position that Montenegro had in 2024 when it was ranked. So not only are we losing competitiveness, but those around us are strengthening that competitiveness. So, in that fight, I think they can emerge as the winner," said Baćović.
Komnenić: Is this, as the Employers' Union claims, a shot at micro, small and medium-sized enterprises?
"It definitely is, because micro, small and medium-sized enterprises have a significantly higher share of labor costs in total costs. So, 60 percent in gross value added is the average for the economy as a whole. The smaller the company, the higher that percentage. So the question is how much they can, meaning even increase the prices of their products and services, to compensate for the cost of labor growth, it is questionable how much they can then market those products and services and whether in principle they can be not even profitable, but whether they can be at zero. And it can have a very significant impact on employment in Montenegro. So now it is questionable what it means in the economy for you to increase the salaries of a certain number of employees in Montenegro, and the price of all this is that the number of employees in Montenegro is falling," said Baćović.
Komnenić: Is that perhaps the reason why there is a rush to adopt this model and why there is a rush to hold elections? In what timeframe do the negative effects of such models become apparent?
"That deadline has been postponed. We had Europe Now 1 and Europe Now 2 and only now can we see some of the negative effects of those models. Regardless of the general narrative that there has been an increase in average net earnings, that is true, 95 percent I think in the last five years. But, in the same period, we have a decline in efficiency of approximately more than seven percent. We have a decline in investment activity, let's just take 2025. So in 2025, gross investments in fixed assets were 27 percent of gross domestic product. Let's exclude 2020 and 2021 for comparison because they are crisis and post-crisis years, so they are never the right years for analysis. In 2019, we had 27 percent, so our investment activity decreased by five percent," said Baćović.
She said that investments are a guarantee of future prosperity, and that investments create new jobs, increase efficiency, the standard of living of citizens, and income.
"So you have this key development category that is five percent lower today than it was in the pre-crisis year. Or you have Montenegrin competitiveness, look at all the international reports from the OECD, the World Bank, the World Intellectual Forum, the reports of the Foreign Investors Council in Montenegro. The business environment, which makes up a lot of components in Montenegro, has been constantly falling in the last few years. Take the Index of Economic Freedom, it is lower in 2026 than it was in 2016. Then you also have these balance imbalances, you have growth, the foreign trade deficit which, for example, has increased in the last few years as a result of the growth of imports. Okay, 2025 was a bit specific because exports decreased due to reduced electricity exports, but if we exclude that, look, 2022, 2023, 2024, now we will look at 2026. So our foreign trade deficit is growing. Low-productivity sectors are getting stronger, trade, hospitality, road transport and public administration, or state administration and that "which is financed by the public sector. The highly productive sector was falling," said Baćović.
Komnenić: The public sector is financed from the economic sector, which is now, as the Employers' Union and some of your colleagues say, under critical attack. In the public sector, we have 80.000 people who are budget dependent, so to speak. On top of that, we have 130.000 pensioners. What does that say about the achievements, the promised structural reforms of this system? And when you put the Euro model in that context, where does that lead us?
"It leads to a further decline in the competitiveness of the economy and perhaps an even further slowdown in economic growth. So, what I may have forgotten to mention is that economic growth in Montenegro has been growing at a rate of about three percent in the last few years, which is completely insufficient for any convergence. The biggest problem of Europe One, Europe Two, and now the Euro model is neither fiscal balance nor imbalance. I have never said that the Montenegrin budget will experience a Greek scenario. I never thought so and I don't think so now. Because you can always balance the budget by reducing expenditures, capital, current. But the main problem is that spending is being forced at the expense of production and productivity. And that stagnation or a decline in inefficiency is being rewarded. So, that is completely against any economic logic," said Baćović.
Komnenić: To what extent is this a whitewash? A billion-euro hole has been created. You say there is no economic growth, no development projects, no investments, no promised new factories. How will this hole be filled and do you expect an increase in VAT? Do you expect the government to take money from those it supposedly rewarded tomorrow in this way again?
"Definitely. Based on these measures, the government will have an increase in current expenditures of some 600 to 700 million euros. If we include the change in corporate income tax, and other tax categories remain unchanged, they will be able to cover some 50 percent of expenditures with inflationary GDP growth. The remaining 50 percent can either be covered by additional taxation, which will then again reduce the disposable income of citizens, or you can borrow abroad.
Komnenić: Do you expect VAT to be 25 percent?
"I don't know if it would reach 25 in the first iteration, but for example, it would be completely logical for me to increase to 23," said Baćović.
Komnenić: And finally, and to conclude. What will this mean for the average citizen you are addressing now? Will his standard of living improve at all, or will we end up the same or worse over time?
"In the medium term, whether we will get worse, maybe not, but we will definitely get the same. What we will lose is perspective. So we have no perspective," said Baćović.
See more:
Download the app and follow the news
FOLLOW US ON
