French lawyers and human rights groups say several teenagers have suffered war-like injuries from police weapons used during student protests, and an unprecedented number of children have been detained by police, some of whom claim they were beaten or racially abused by officers, the Guardian newspaper reported today.
France has entered the fourth week of the biggest youth protest movement in decades. Hundreds of high schools across the country have been blocked during the protests, with students demanding replacements for absent teachers and repairs to dilapidated school buildings.
Police have launched internal investigations into 36 reports of violence by police officers against protesters, including the cases of four children who reportedly suffered serious injuries with lasting consequences from explosive police weapons, while six others suffered "serious injuries", the Guardian reported in an article on its website.
The reports include allegations of physical violence, insults and alleged sexual assault, Interior Minister Laurent Nunez told the French Senate.
Fifteen-year-old Evan, a carpentry student at a vocational high school, had his hand blown off in a police stun grenade explosion during a protest outside a school in Lens, northern France, on October 5th.
His lawyer Bertrand Watte said: "His injuries resemble war injuries."
Vate said that Evan had come to the school to attend classes and that he had found the protest there. He stated that Evan had not participated in the violence and rejected the claim by the state prosecutor in Betina that the boy had picked up the bomb from the ground.
When the bomb exploded, Evan lost his left hand and several fingers on his right hand, and suffered injuries to other parts of his body. He remains in hospital in "very serious condition" and his family has filed a criminal complaint, Vate said.
Another boy, 14-year-old Eden, who was near a student protest in Saint-Ouen-l'Aumont, northwest of Paris, suffered serious facial injuries, including two broken jaws, the loss of all his lower teeth and the breakage of all his upper teeth, after he was allegedly hit by a grenade launcher projectile.
His lawyer, Elsa Marcel, stated that the grenade launcher projectile was fired at close range, from a distance of only one and a half meters.
"This is the equivalent of weapons of war," said Marsel.
The boy's family filed a criminal complaint for attempted murder.
Eden's parents said their son came to school, but found a roadblock and wanted to return home.
The video appears to show Eden standing in front of three riot police officers. One of the officers swung a baton at him, and Eden then kicked the officers before a grenade launcher was fired, according to the Guardian.
One police officer was suspended and an official investigation was launched against him.
This week, a police officer in the western French city of Tours was charged with causing grievous bodily harm under aggravated circumstances after 16-year-old Mael, a secondary school student, lost sight in one eye, allegedly after being hit by a projectile from a rubber bullet launcher. The officer denies the charges.
The family's lawyer said that Mael did not participate in any violent confrontation with the police, but was merely attending a student protest, and that his family felt a great "injustice."
France has faced criticism for years over its police use of explosive weapons, particularly after serious injuries to protesters were reported during the "yellow vest" street protests of 2018 and 2019, including cases where people reportedly lost their eyes or suffered serious injuries to their hands and feet.
The current wave of protests has also raised concerns among lawyers about the unprecedented number of children being arrested and held in police custody. Some lawyers say teenagers have told them they were beaten, humiliated or verbally abused during their arrests.
Since the beginning of the student protests in mid-September, a total of 6.773 minors under the age of 18 have been arrested and held in police custody, the Ministry of Justice said.
More than 1.000 of these children have not been charged, while 2.190 are facing legal proceedings. Almost 2.000 minors have been given alternative measures to further prosecution, such as attending a civic education course, without trial or conviction.
Lawyers stated that the charges against the minors relate to gathering with the intent to commit violence, violence against police officers, and damage to property.
Natalie Teio, a lawyer and president of the French League for Human Rights, said that the fact that only a small number of cases against minors will end up before a judge raises concerns that the arrests may be unfounded.
"We are seeing record numbers of arrests. Often the court files are practically empty. In reality, this is more about preventing people from demonstrating. I think there is an intention to use harsh treatment to deter people from protesting and to intimidate them," Teio said.
"We have received testimonies about racist comments. Lawyers have told us that their clients claim that they were humiliated, that violence was used against them or that police officers pushed them," she added.
Romain Boulet, co-president of the French Association of Criminal Lawyers, said: "Criminal lawyers are concerned and warn of the possible abuse of police powers to dissuade citizens under 18 from participating in demonstrations."
Mohamed Jaite, president of the Paris branch of the left-wing Syndicat des Avocats de France, represented several teenagers stopped by police in Paris and its suburbs.
"I saw a young man limping in the police station. Some reported being humiliated or subjected to racist and sexist insults," said Dzhaite.
See more:
Download the app and follow the news
FOLLOW US ON