Is Iran heading towards a nuclear bomb: It cannot be done without the IAEA, Western intelligence services cannot be honest

Without verification by international atomic watchdogs, no one can know how enriched Iran's uranium is.

3141 views 2 comment(s)
Illustration, Photo: Shutterstock
Illustration, Photo: Shutterstock
Disclaimer: The translations are mostly done through AI translator and might not be 100% accurate.

While Israel and the United States (USA) claim that Iran is once again rapidly working on an atomic bomb, contradictory messages are coming from Tehran.

Without verification by international atomic inspectors, no one can know how enriched Iran's uranium is.

Iran is one step away from a nuclear bomb – a warning that has been repeated for decades by opponents of the regime in Tehran, especially those in Israel and the US.

But now even independent observers are wondering whether Iran has come close to building nuclear weapons. Or, at least, whether such an attitude has prevailed within the regime.

President Masoud Pezizian denied last week that Tehran was moving towards a bomb, citing an Islamic fatwa that forbids Tehran from developing such weapons. He also said that Iran was ready to dilute its enriched uranium and accept international inspections if a comprehensive peace agreement was reached.

Contradictory statements from Iran

But while Pezeshkian was diplomatic, Iran's Press TV - the government's main English-language satellite channel - struck a different tone. There, Mohsen Rezai, secretary of the Supreme National Security Council, said that the US and Israeli attacks gave Iran the right to leave the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty.

The treaty lists the US, Russia, the UK, France and China as nuclear weapons "users". Countries known to possess nuclear weapons – India, Pakistan, North Korea and Israel – are also not part of the treaty.

Rezai, however, says that no decision has been made in Tehran on whether to leave the agreement.

According to the Daily Telegraph, satellite images show that Iran is renovating facilities and building new ones, including those buried under mountains. The locations mentioned by the newspaper have been targeted by Israeli and American bombs.

This has fueled speculation about whether Iran has already rebuilt its nuclear facilities or even hidden them deeper in the country.

As for US President Donald Trump, who has already boasted that Iran's nuclear program has been destroyed forever, he is sticking to the same: "I will never allow Iran to possess nuclear weapons," he said at the recent UN General Assembly.

What about diplomacy?

The previous nuclear agreement with Iran, which Donald Trump unilaterally abandoned in his first term, provided for inspections by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA).

But this has been a matter of dispute all along. The Trump administration has argued that the inspections are invalid and that the IAEA does not have full access.

John Bolton, a political hawk and former Trump national security adviser, claims that the agreement was just a fig leaf and that the IAEA was never able to enter military bases where Iranians are allegedly working to use enriched uranium for military purposes.

As Bolton added to Deutsche Welle (DW), Iran has been violating agreements for decades anyway, so it will make no difference if it officially withdraws from the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty. "The overthrow of the regime in Tehran is the only long-term path to peace and security in the Middle East."

War strengthens Tehran's resolve

American allies, as well as Russia and China, criticized the US at the time for abandoning the agreement with Iran, arguing that it - along with the lifting of sanctions - was the best way to prevent the creation of a nuclear bomb.

Now the IAEA itself is reporting Iran for alleged violations of its non-proliferation obligations.

What next? The two-month deadline for turning the initial agreement between Washington and Tehran into a comprehensive peace agreement that would also define what to do with the nuclear program expired in mid-August.

Despite Trump's boasting, Damon Golriz, a political analyst and lecturer at The Hague University of Applied Sciences, says Donald Trump's "greatest foreign policy legacy" could be a nuclear-armed Iran.

Golriz recalls that in the first Israeli strikes on Iran in early 2026, Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei was killed, as well as entire layers of the military and security apparatus and a number of key scientists who worked on the nuclear program.

"Tehran was then facing an existential war," he tells DW.

In Golriz's interpretation, it was precisely the audacity in choosing targets in Iran that prompted the leadership in Tehran to reconsider its nuclear doctrine.

The younger Khamenei is silent.

This is where a specific fatwa, an official religious edict that prohibits Iranians from having nuclear weapons, comes into play. It has been invoked for two decades, and Ali Khamenei publicly confirmed the fatwa in 2019, when he said that the production and stockpiling of nuclear weapons are prohibited.

However, his son and successor, Mojtaba Khamenei, is silent about this.

That silence could be telling, says Tim Bosch, a former Dutch intelligence officer and now at the security consultancy Birdwatcher Group.

Bosch tells DW that there is no final proof of a change in Tehran's nuclear doctrine, and that "those in Tehran who oppose the development of nuclear weapons are now much weaker."

As recently as late 2024, the IAEA estimated that Iran was the only non-nuclear bomb state to possess uranium enriched to 60 percent, warning that Tehran was "dramatically accelerating" enrichment. 90 percent purity is required to produce nuclear weapons.

Today, no one can say for sure how far Iran has come. Bosch says that without independent verification by the IAEA, no Western intelligence agency can "fairly claim" that Iran has actually decided to build a bomb.

"Those who categorically claim this are either bluffing or mostly pushing their own political agendas – both hardliners in Iran and hardliners in Israel and the United States," Bosch adds.

See more: